‘Billy’ over Brody: Why the Pies have to make Elliott their priority

‘Billy’ over Brody: Why the Pies Have to Make Elliott Their Priority

Collingwood has some of the biggest list management decisions in the AFL right now, but one stands out above the rest: whether to put their faith – and their dollars – into Jamie “Billy” Elliott or Brody Mihocek. Both forwards have been pivotal to the club’s rise and sustained success, but when it comes to who should be the absolute priority in contract negotiations, the answer is clear. Billy Elliott’s unique influence, versatility, and leadership make him irreplaceable.

The Heartbeat of Collingwood’s Forward Line

Elliott isn’t just another small forward – he’s the heartbeat of Collingwood’s attack. Since debuting in 2012, he has consistently provided match-winning moments that swing momentum and break open games. His agility, ability to crumb packs, and uncanny knack for producing goals from impossible angles have made him one of the league’s most dangerous players inside 50.

While Mihocek is the ultimate workhorse and a reliable marking target, Elliott offers something that can’t be coached: unpredictability. Opposition defenders know he can hurt them in so many different ways – at ground level, on the lead, or with a spectacular grab. That capacity to change a game in a matter of minutes is why the Pies must prioritise him.

A Symbol of Resilience

Elliott’s journey has been anything but smooth. Multiple injuries, including serious back and hamstring problems, could have ended his career years ago. Instead, he rebuilt his body, adjusted his game, and returned to elite level football. That resilience resonates deeply with Collingwood supporters and teammates alike.

He embodies the “never say die” spirit of the club. Every time he runs out onto the MCG, fans know they’re watching a player who has fought for every game he plays. That spirit alone makes him worth more than his goals – it sets the tone for the younger forwards coming through, teaching them about persistence and professionalism.

The Big-Game Factor

Elliott thrives when the pressure is at its peak. Finals footy is about moments, and Collingwood has always turned to Elliott for those. His ability to deliver in clutch situations – whether it’s a boundary-line snap, a contested mark, or a goal after the siren – gives the Magpies the edge.

Mihocek, while consistent, doesn’t carry the same aura in high-stakes games. He provides structure and reliability, but it’s Elliott’s flair and courage that fans remember long after the siren. In a competition where one player can define September, Elliott’s X-factor is invaluable.

Marketability and Connection

Beyond the stats sheet, Elliott has become a face of the Collingwood brand. His flair, tattoos, and on-field personality make him a cult figure. Kids in black and white guernseys imitate his celebrations. Sponsors see value in him because he represents the Collingwood style – hard, creative, and uncompromising.

That off-field connection matters. Elliott doesn’t just win games; he draws people through the gates and strengthens the emotional bond between the club and its supporters. When list managers look at priorities, they can’t ignore that.

Why Not Both?

Of course, in a perfect world, Collingwood would retain both Elliott and Mihocek. Each offers something unique – Mihocek’s endurance and contested marking balance out Elliott’s explosiveness and flair. But salary caps force tough calls. When those decisions arrive, the Pies must ask themselves: who can’t we replace?

Tall forwards like Mihocek, though hard to find, can be developed over time. Smaller, game-breaking forwards with Elliott’s specific skill set and proven record are rare. If forced to choose, Collingwood cannot afford to lose Billy.

The Verdict

As the Pies chase more premiership glory, they need their proven match-winners on the park. Elliott is more than just a forward – he’s a leader, a fighter, and a game-changer. Collingwood’s success has always been built on players who rise when the pressure is greatest.

That’s why the Pies must prioritise “Billy” over Brody. Elliott isn’t just a luxury; he’s a necessity.

–