September 16, 2024

Detroit Lions Free Agency: Best and Worst of the Last 5 Years

If the 2011 offseason taught Detroit Lions fans anything, it’s that impact players do not always have to come from the draft.

The Lions entered the 2011 draft with major needs at linebacker and cornerback. They drafted a defensive tackle, running back and wide receiver in the first two rounds.

It was worrisome, since the lockout eliminated free agency before the draft. Normally, teams have a little over a month to fill glaring needs on the team with existing players before they bring in the new blood in April.

This year, the gaps stayed open until August. And then, just at the advent of free agency, Stephen Tulloch, Eric Wright and Justin Durant joined the team and took a scrap heap of a defensive back seven and made it respectable.

Granted, it isn’t infallible, but it’s much better than it was, and there is little doubt that the addition of these players (all of whom started every game they were available) had a major impact on the Lions’ fortunes in 2011.

For all the talk about the difference in draft fortunes between Lions GMs (and if you need a refresher, check out my previous piece), equally important and striking is the differences in free agency decisions.

Don’t believe me? Remember Az-Zahir Hakim, who was signed not once, but twice by the Lions, and didn’t produce anything of note either time? Exactly. Free-agent busts are just as important as draft busts.

And so with that established, let’s revisit the Lions’ recent free-agency decisions. In doing so, I will highlight the best and worst signings (either new players or re-signed unrestricted free agents) each year, the biggest impact trade (good or bad) and the “addition by subtraction” award for the best decision to let a guy walk.

Got it? Good. Let’s do it.

2007: Who Are These People?

1 OF 5

Best Addition: Shaun McDonald, WR (from St. Louis Rams)

Actually, this is only because I can’t break my own rule.

In reality, the best free-agency move the Lions made this offseason is re-signing long-snapper Don Muhlbach, the only player from the 2007 free-agency period that remains on the team.

But give some credit when it’s due. In 2007, Shaun McDonald led the Lions in receptions (79), receiving yardage (943) and receiving touchdowns (eight).

That’s more than Roy Williams and Calvin Johnson had during the one Millen year that the Lions actually had a competent passing offense under Mike Martz and Jon Kitna.

Sure, he was irrelevant by the end of the 2008 season, but hey, who on the team wasn’t?

Worst Addition: Mike Furrey, WR (Re-signed as UFA)

In 2006, Mike Furrey was one of the best feel-good stories of the season. A former undrafted free-agent safety-turned-receiver, Furrey notched 98 catches for over 1,000 yards in 2006 while playing on a $500,000 one-year contract.

So theoretically, it only made sense to pay the man who was Wes Welker before being Wes Welker was cool.

The hindsight on that move isn’t so kind. He played two years on a three-year deal, made just under $7.5 million and what did the Lions have to show for it?

In 2007 and 2008 combined, Furrey notched a total of 79 catches for 845 yards and one touchdown. Pretty good numbers for one season. Not very good for two seasons. Even worse when your numbers for 2007-2008 combined drop off from 2006 alone.

Impact Trade: Dre’ Bly and a 2007 sixth-round pick to Denver Broncos for George Foster, Tatum Bell, and a 2007 fifth-round pick

I’m feeling nauseous just thinking about this, so let me just boil it down to essentials by describing each player’s contribution to the Lions.

Dre’ Bly was the best cornerback the Lions had all decade and even made three Pro Bowls in Detroit.

George “False Start” Foster earned the nickname “False Start” Foster while playing in Detroit, and his poor play facilitated the need for the Lions to draft Gosder Cherilus the following year.

Tatum Bell is best remembered for stealing Rudi Johnson’s luggage on his way into town.

And the fifth-round pick? Linebacker Johnny Baldwin out of Alabama A&M, who was cut during training camp. Baldwin would later go on to get cut by both the Winnipeg Blue Bombers and California Redwoods.

Addition by Subtraction: Shawn Bryson, RB (released, no NFL interest since)

It’s hard to pick one.

The Lions weren’t so concerned with cutting bad players in 2007; they were too busy signing them all to three-year contracts.

But really, the Lions dealt almost exclusively in bad players in 2007. Every player they cut fell out of the league, and every player they signed eventually got cut and then fell out of the league.

So why Bryson specifically? After several seasons of being part of perhaps the worst running back committee ever, he played six games in 2006, notching one rushing yard on two carries.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *